Preservation Battle Over Lincoln Park’s Second Church of Christ, Scientist

By Alex Bean on July 19, 2018

TOURSDAILY

The Second Church of Christ, Scientist in Lincoln Park is at the center of a bubbling preservation battle. The congregation has shrunk precipitously and can no longer afford their historic venue. Thus, a battle has erupted between the forces of architectural preservation, led by the venerable Preservation Chicago, and those of commercial development. It is just one example of the preservation battle happening with historic buildings across the country. I’ve also got some skin in this game, since I live right around the corner.

History of the Second Church of Christ, Scientist

125th anniversary of the 1893 World's Fair Ferris Wheel Lincoln Park construction Second Church of Christ, Scientist preservation battle
The original Ferris Wheel during its reconstruction two blocks from the Second Church of Christ, Scientist. Image via Wikimedia.

The church is located just a block from Lincoln Park in the eponymous neighborhood. Built in 1901, the Second Church of Christ, Scientist is a notable landmark in the area.

Back then this slice of the neighborhood was among the most elite parts of the city. Notables like former Governor John Peter Altgeld lived around the corner. The area is strewn with historic mansions, perhaps most notably the Wrigley and Dewes houses. The new Christian Scientist church aimed to appeal directly to the refined sensibilities of these neighbors, who were open to new religious approaches.

The Christian Scientist denomination originated with a New England woman named Mary Baker Eddy. Like many other 19th-century Yankees, she spun the traditional Protestant faith of her forebears into a new denomination. She preached that illness was an illusion that only prayer could alleviate. She garnered many upper crust followers. The most well-to-do people were particularly exposed to new advances in industry and science. As they tried to reconcile their religious beliefs with changing times, Victorian-era people, like the inhabitants of Lincoln Park, looked to metaphysical explanations such as those of Eddy for the few remaining mysteries of the world.

Architecture from the Columbian Exposition

second church of Christ, Scientist Lincoln Park Chicago
The stately neoclassical facade facing onto Wrightwood. Photo by Alex Bean

I live in the neighborhood, and have marveled at the neo-classical grandeur of the Second Church of Christ, Scientist. Chicago architect Solon S. Beman designed it. His most famous work is the planned Pullman community on the Far South Side. But that only scratches the surface of his prodigious career. Beman also designed Chicago landmarks like the Fine Arts Building (which our 1893 World’s Fair Tour visits) and the now-demolished Grand Central Station of Chicago.

The Columbian Exposition, also known as our beloved 1893 World’s Fair, had an indelible impact on his style. The Beaux Arts neoclassicism which Daniel Burnham supported became Beman’s template for his Merchant Tailors’ Building. Beman basically recycled the design for that building for the Second Church of Christ, Scientist here in Lincoln Park.

Both the Merchant Tailors’ Building and the church building are perfect examples of neoclassical design. Beman designed the facade to mimic that of an ancient Greek or Roman temple. A line of Ionic capitol columns hold up the entablature straight out of ancient Athens. A soaring dome vaults up behind the facade, giving the worship space a dramatic flair. Beman’s work here became the model for numerable other Christian Scientist churches. I’ve always loved its stately presence on the block.

The Core of the Preservation Battle

Second Church of Christ, Scientist Pine Grove facade Lincoln Park preservation battle
The Pine Grove Avenue facade of the church hints at its soaring interior space. Photo by Alex Bean

Today, the congregation cannot support their historic home. The Christian Scientist denomination’s membership across the country has fallen dramatically. In fact, this congregation reportedly has only 12-15 members. Dozens of churches have shuttered across the country. The Lincoln Park congregation reportedly needs $4 million in repairs, which the limited number of congregants cannot hope to cover.

According to an article in the Inside-Booster, Ward Miller, the Executive Director of Preservation Chicago, approached them with an offer to convert the building into a cultural center. An unnamed local non-profit foundation wanted to preserve the historic building and then convert it into a Lincoln Park equivalent to downtown’s Cultural Center. They even offered to let the congregation continue to meet for services on Sundays and holy days.

Unfortunately, the congregation rejected this offer in the hopes of selling the property to a residential developer. The most likely outcome of such a sale would be either full demolition or a facade-ectomy. Either way, for this neighborhood the architecture would be yet another mid-rise glass-clad condo building. Three other high-rise buildings are already under construction within a block. Some in the community have wondered if the small congregation are hoping for a personal windfall if they sell the building for commercial redevelopment.

The ultimate fate of the building within this preservation battle is unknowable but certain. The congregation which has met here for over a century will soon attend services for the last time. What happens next remains to be seen, but it will reflect the ongoing battle between the architecture of our past and the architecture of our future here in Chicago.

-Alex Bean, Content Manager and Tour Guide