A Helping of Famous Chicago Food History

By Amanda on April 26, 2016

TOURSDAILY

Let’s talk about famous Chicago food history to welcome the James Beard Awards to Chicago for the second year in a row on May 2nd. Considered the “Oscars of Food,” these awards will go to the best American restaurants, chefs, and bakers. Since I don’t regularly dine at Alinea, a very high-class Chicago institution, it seemed more appropriate to write up some of the working class dishes that make up so much of famous Chicago food history.

famous Chicago food history Maxwell Street Polish
Jim’s Original is no longer at Maxwell and Halsted, but it is the stand that created the Maxwell Street Polish.

Maxwell Street Polish

The Maxwell Street Polish is a beef and pork Polish sausage topped with grilled onions and yellow mustard. This bit of famous Chicago food history can be grilled or fried, which sets it apart from the tradtional Chicago Hot Dog. It originated at Jim’s Original, a food stand located at Halsted and Maxwell (duh), in the heart of the old Maxwell Street Market.

Curiously, that original Jim who is credited with inventing the Maxwell Street Polish was Macedonian. Perhaps that explains why Pawel, our resident Polish staffer, has never loved the Maxwell Street Polish. He says it’s good eating, but not authentically Polish. I guess I’ll have to take his word on that, since I am Scottish, Irish, Dutch, and German.

famous Chicago food history deep-dish pizza
Deep-dish pizza is likely the single most famous Chicago food.

Chicago Deep-Dish Pizza

I’d bet anyone a Coke that deep-dish pizza is the single most famous Chicago food. Beloved by many, hated by fools, the Chicago-style deep-dish pizza is a deliciously monstrous creation. The size and scope of these pizzas are what set them apart from standard fare. Deep-dish pizza crusts rise 2 to 3 inches above the plate. A bevy of toppings along with a small mountain of cheese and tomato sauce fill the crust.

Tim Samuelson, Chicago’s official cultural historian, could find no consensus about who actually invented the deep-dish pizza. It was almost certainly first created at what’s now Pizzeria Uno. The thick crust likely originates from Sicilian-style pizza. The actual genius who first made this particular pie? A bevy of contenders claim the title. But Samuelson says none can conclusively prove their case.

The Chicago Hot Dog in Famous Chicago Food History

The Chicago hot dog is such a huge part of famous Chicago food history that we could write a whole article about it. Oh, wait, we have done exactly that.

Breaded Steak Sandwich

Never heard of this one? It’s fame is just starting to spread outside of Chicago’s South Side. As you can guess, the key component here is a juicy and tender breaded and fried steak. Sweet tomato sauce, gooey melted mozzarella, and a heap of spicy giardiniera top it off. Supposedly a hero bun keep this whole thing together, but I have my doubts.

Last year, USA Today named the breaded steak sandwich at Ricobene’s in Bridgeport the single best sandwich in the world. Some locals disagree, but the hype is enough that Anthony Bourdain visited Ricobene’s to taste it for an upcoming episode of his CNN series Parts Unknown. That press hype will surely rocket it into every diner and independent fast food joint in Chicagoland.

famous Chicago food history Mother-in-law sandwich
The Mother-in-law sandwich is a South Side speciality and an increasingly famous Chicago food. (Image credit: Southern Foodways Alliance)

Mother-In-Law Sandwich

The mother-in-law sandwich, much like the breaded steak, is a meal that hovers right on the edge of famous Chicago food history. Imagine a chili dog with a ground beef tamale subbing in for the sausage. I got to eat one on Chicago Detours’ Big Shoulders Historic Bar and Food Bus Tour, which is normally just offered for private groups. My mother-in-law sandwich from Johnny O’s was also topped with the tomato, pickle, and onions one would expect from a Chicago dog. As you can imagine, that’s a heavy-duty sandwich. In fact, it made me feel about ten pounds heavier, in a most enjoyable way.  That sinking feeling in your gut often associated with mothers-in-law is where the name comes from.

The mother-in-law sandwich is a South Side speciality that’s been crawling into the limelight. A Smithsonian article writes about its rarity and Bourdain, again, sought it out for his TV show. He called it “the evil stepbrother of the hot dog,” and “disturbing in design, yet strangely compelling.” Sounds like an endorsement to me!

It’s unlikely that any of these dishes will be up for James Beard Awards anytime soon, but they exemplify what makes Chicago such a famous foodie hotspot.

– Amanda Scotese, Executive Director and Alex Bean, Office Manager and Tour Guide